Ethos Community

How does coaching differ from consultancy? A quick comparison

There are many differences between a coach and a consultant, although, at first glance some of them may not be obvious, especially in the context of business. One way of thinking about it is to compare the following scenarios where the goal is to integrate horse riding into your life / business:

Working with a coach would support you to identify exactly why you are keen to learn to ride a horse, and to develop an understanding of how to go about it, and identify things that may help you or challenge you while learning to ride a horse. They wouldn’t tell you how to ride though. The coach would ask questions and provide feedback though that would help you recognise breakthroughs, and setbacks (such as your first fall), as well as areas you need to work on the next time you ride.


In comparison:

You would bring in a consultant to provide an overview of the benefits, given your needs, of certain horse breeds, and make recommendations of what you need to look for when you purchase one, as well as some of the risks of riding. They would provide guidelines how to go about buying, and then riding your horse. If required the consultant would also demonstrate the finer points of equitation, and if requested, initially ride your newly purchased horse for you.

The scenarios help illustrate that with coaching, the professional relationship between the coach and the coachee requires one to ‘walk beside’ the other in their context, while the coachee undertakes a professional learning journey. The coachee is seen as whole, motivated, and having the resources and answers within them; the coach facilitates a process which helps surface and structure the coachee’s strategies and ideas, but the coach does not provide advice. Mistakes are framed as things to be learned from, so trying things differently is seen as positive. Change is often quickly realised, and is part of a cumulative shift toward increased insights, skills, and possible shifts in beliefs and professional identity.

Most people will, on the other hand, bring in a consultant for advice around a specific focus, to, for example, provide solutions to existing issues, identification of risks and possible mitigations, and, where required develop a high-level strategic plan (which might include guidelines for managing change) to achieve outcomes based on a client’s needs. This is an ‘expert model’ where the consultant has deep, up-to-date, research-informed knowledge about a specific area, and so will be able to suggest answers / solutions, effective practice in other contexts, and implications. The client is viewed as capable and resourceful, but needing guidance. They might (initially) head up the initiative. The consultant’s involvement is sometimes (but not always) viewed as short-term with the client moving on to implement the plan, either heading it up themselves or working with a team.

Image: Pacino. CC ( BY NC SA ) licensed Flickr image by hazelowendmc:

Views: 55

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Ethos Community to add comments!

Join Ethos Community

© 2020   Created by Hazel Owen.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service